Priya and Arjun applied for the same position as a promotion at a top tech company they have been working for. Priya was known for her networking skills—she built strong relationships with managers, seniors, office staff and all team members and connected with industry professionals on LinkedIn. On the other hand, Arjun spent most of his time honing his coding skills, participating in hackathons, and contributing to open-source projects. When the promotion offer came, it went to Arjun. Priya was left wondering: Was all her networking enough, or did Arjun’s technical skills give him the promotion?
However, relationships and social connections also play an important role in getting promotions. While strong relationships can be helpful, only promoting people based on connections rather than skills can hurt the organization and lead to unfair results.
In today’s competitive job market, students often wonder what factors drive career growth. As you get ready to start your careers, you probably begin to think: Are promotions mainly based on the relationships you make, or do your skills matter?
Relationships in Promotions
In any work environment, building good relationships with your colleagues, managers, and even clients can be crucial. Why? Because of the power of relationships, discussed next, people tend to support and promote those they trust and get along with.
The Power of Relationships:
1. Networking as a Key Factor:
Networking can really open doors. Building connections with peers, mentors, and industry professionals can lead to great career opportunities. Many jobs are filled through referrals or internal promotions, where those in charge prefer candidates they know and trust. Having a strong professional network can be crucial in getting promoted.
2. Visibility and Reputation:
Building relationships within your organization can help you get noticed. When your colleagues and supervisors know you—your work ethic, contributions, and character—they’re more likely to support you during promotion discussions. A good reputation can lead to more chances for advancement, as people tend to promote those they trust and respect.
3. Mentorship:
Having a mentor can greatly influence your career path. A mentor not only offers guidance and advice but can also support you during promotion talks. They can help you understand office politics and what skills and experiences are important in your field.
However, relying only on relationships has its drawbacks. If you don’t have the skills to match your connections, it’s tough to keep up. Imagine being promoted to a higher position but struggling because you lack the necessary skills. It wouldn’t take long for others to notice, and it could put your job at risk.
Findings
A wealth of research has demonstrated the influence that relationships have on career outcomes like promotions.
- Several key studies have found: Employees with more central network positions in their organization’s social network are more likely to be noticed and given new responsibilities that could lead to promotion (Podolny and Baron 1997).
- Those who are socially connected to senior leaders and decision-makers tend to advance more quickly, as sponsors and advocates within their networks support and endorse their candidacy for new roles (Burt 1992; Fernandez and Weinberg 1997).
- Employees perceived as socially attractive or well-liked by colleagues are judged more favourably and afforded greater opportunities than equally qualified but less popular candidates (Cable and Judge 2003; van Rijswijk et al. 2006).
While skills and experience are important, having people who can vouch for you can make a big difference. This suggests that promotions often go to those who are good at building relationships and navigating office politics, rather than just the most qualified candidates.
Strengthen Your Relationships
Here are five simple actions you can take to strengthen your relationships and increase your chances of getting promoted:
1. Share Your Strengths:
Identify what makes you great at your job and share those skills with others. This not only helps your team but also shows management that you can work well with others.
2. Shift from “Me” to “We”:
Understand how others see you and focus on teamwork. Seek feedback to improve how you work with others, and show that you’re a team player.
3. Mentor Others:
Start mentoring colleagues to develop your leadership skills. Helping others grow will not only improve your own skills but also build strong professional relationships.
4. Work Well with Difficult Personalities:
Learn to work productively with people you find challenging. Developing strategies to handle different personalities will make you a more effective and promotable team member.
5. Set Healthy Boundaries:
Focus on the most important tasks and learn when to say no. Prioritize projects that will help you grow and make an impact, rather than taking on everything. This will show that you can manage responsibilities wisely.
Potential Issues with Focusing on Relationships for Promotions
When promotions are based more on who you know rather than your qualifications, it can lead to several problems:
1. Bias and Unequal Opportunities:
People without strong connections or outgoing personalities might be overlooked, regardless of their actual skills.
2. Limited Perspectives:
Relying on close-knit networks can ignore talented individuals from outside these circles, stifling creativity and new ideas.
3. Inefficiency:
Less qualified but socially connected individuals may get promoted, leading to poor performance and wasted resources.
4. Unfair Perceptions:
If promotions seem random or based on luck, it can lower morale and lead to high turnover among skilled employees.
The Importance of Skills
1. Competence and Contribution:
Promotions are largely based on your skills and abilities. Employers need to see that you can effectively contribute to the organization. Key skills like problem-solving, critical thinking, and technical expertise are essential. Showing consistent competence and delivering results can set you apart, regardless of your network.
2. Continuous Learning and Adaptability:
Staying relevant is crucial in a fast-evolving job market. Engaging in continuous learning through education, online courses, or professional development demonstrates your commitment. Being adaptable to new technologies and methods can make you an invaluable asset, leading to promotions based on merit.
3. Performance and Metrics:
Organizations often use performance metrics to evaluate promotions. Your ability to meet or exceed targets directly impacts your career advancement. Skills that produce measurable results—such as successful project management, sales achievements, or innovation—can significantly enhance your chances for promotion.
Balancing Relationships and Skills
So, which is more important—relationships or skills? The answer is both. Relationships can open doors, but your skills will determine how well you can walk through those doors.
Here’s how to strike the right balance:
1. Cultivate Relationships:
Connect with peers and professionals in your field. Attend networking events, join professional organizations, and seek mentorship. A strong network can provide opportunities that skills alone might not.
2. Invest in Skills Development:
Focus on building a strong skill set relevant to your career goals. Pursue internships, volunteer work, and projects to apply and improve your abilities.
3. Communicate Your Achievements:
Regularly share your skills and accomplishments with your network. Update mentors and connections on your progress, as this can lead to new opportunities and recommendations.
4. Be Authentic:
Build relationships genuinely. People are more likely to support and promote those they trust and believe in
Conclusion
Promotions are not just about who you know or what you know, but how well you blend both to add value to your organization. To advance in your career, focus on developing your skills and building strong relationships. Balancing these two aspects is key to success.
Whether you’re starting your career or are already working, keep learning, stay connected, and work on both your skills and network. This approach will help you navigate your professional journey and increase your chances of getting that promotion.
FAQs
1. Is experience more important than skills?
Experience and skills both play crucial roles in securing a promotion, but experience often holds greater weight. It provides a deep understanding of job-specific tasks, company culture, and processes, showcasing a proven track record and reliability over time. Experienced employees are typically better equipped to handle responsibilities and navigate challenges. However, skills are equally important, demonstrating the ability to adapt, innovate, and meet new demands. A balance of both is ideal, with experience being prioritized for roles requiring extensive knowledge, while skills become essential for positions that focus on innovation and advanced expertise. Ultimately, proving value in both areas is key.
2. What are the benefits of promotion?
Benefits of Promotions:
- Higher Salary: Increases financial security and job satisfaction.
- More Responsibilities: Allows employees to showcase their skills and leadership abilities.
- Improved Job Security: Recognizes hard work and contributions, making employees feel valued.
- Professional Growth: Provides opportunities to learn new skills and advance in their careers.
- Boosted Morale and Motivation: Fosters a sense of achievement and encourages commitment to the organization.
3. What are the four importance of promotion?
Here are four importance of promotion:
- Career Growth: Promotions help employees climb the career ladder and take on more challenging jobs.
- Boosted Motivation: Getting a promotion lifts employee spirits and motivates them to work harder and stay committed to their tasks and the company.
- Acknowledgment of Hard Work: Promotions recognize and reward employees for their effort and dedication, creating a positive workplace.
- Skill Improvement: Promotions bring new challenges that help employees develop their skills, making them more competent and improving their career opportunities.
4. How is skill important in life?
Skills are important in life because they help you perform tasks effectively and efficiently. Whether it’s communication, problem-solving, or technical know-how, skills allow you to tackle different challenges in life. They promote independence, build confidence, and create job opportunities. By continuously learning and developing skills, you stay adaptable and competitive in a changing world. Ultimately, skills empower you to reach both personal and professional goals, making life more rewarding and fulfilling.
Social