7 ways classroom teaching is better than online education

There has been a surge in the popularity of online learning technology both before and after the pandemic. This shift has left many teachers, parents, and school administrators wondering whether it is better for children than traditional classroom learning. So what is better for learning: a teacher or the Internet? Does online teaching effectively replicate the benefits of traditional classroom teaching? Can students maintain focus during online classes? Is classroom learning better than online learning in the 21st century? All these questions lead to the debate on whether to continue online instruction or switch to classroom-based learning.

In India, the debate over classroom versus online learning is complicated by disparities in digital infrastructure. Most public and affordable private schools do not have proper internet access or the infrastructure. According to the recent UDISE report from the Union education ministry, while more than 90% of schools in the country are equipped with basic amenities such as electricity and gender-specific toilets, advanced facilities like functional desktops and Internet access remain scarce. However, only 57% of schools have functional computers and 53% have Internet access. Also, the majority of students in rural areas lack access to essential devices such as laptops, tablets, mobile phones, and smart TVs. and poor connectivity. This makes it difficult for schools to rely on online learning platforms.

In an era where technology has revolutionized, classroom and online teaching remains a hot topic for discussion. Now, let us understand the various aspects in detail. 

What is classroom teaching?

Classroom teaching is the cornerstone of traditional education, where a qualified and trained instructor guides students in a physical space. It’s a dynamic environment where knowledge is imparted through various methods like lectures, discussions, examples, activities, and demonstrations. Teachers can tailor their approach to the specific needs of their students, fostering a sense of community and social interaction beyond academics. This face-to-face interaction allows for real-time feedback, personalized guidance, and a stimulating learning environment that can spark curiosity and ignite a passion for lifelong learning.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of classroom teaching?

Classroom teaching offers a unique combination of structure and flexibility that can benefit students. Here’s a breakdown of its advantages and disadvantages:

Benefits of classroom learning:

• Structured learning environment: A set routine ensures consistency and helps develop study habits and time management to complete assignments and manage priorities.
• Interaction and collaboration: Classrooms encourage social interaction by providing opportunities for students to participate in discussions and interact with their peers through debates, group projects, etc. It develops critical thinking, communication, problem-solving skills, and encourages teamwork.
• Immediate feedback and personalized support: Teachers play a vital role in student achievement by providing personalized support, clarifying questions for a deeper understanding. Additionally, immediate feedback helps students identify areas for improvement.

Disadvantages:

• Limited Individualized Attention: Large class sizes can make it difficult for teachers to pace students as some learn quickly, while others have difficulty understanding.
• Different Learning Styles: Traditional classroom teaching might not accommodate the different learning styles of visual, auditory, and kinesthetic learners as effectively as online education.
• Potential for Distractions: Classroom learning environments can be distracting for students due to disturbance from classmates or external factors like construction noise or uncomfortable temperatures.
• Fixed Schedules: Fixed schedules can be inconvenient for students who participate in sports and other extracurricular activities and find it difficult to balance their commitments with class time.

What is online education?

Online learning, also known as e-learning, uses the internet to deliver educational content  guidance. Online education provides access to study materials, virtual participation in interactive tasks, and communication with teachers and peers. This encourages students to learn from anywhere if they have access to the internet, at their own pace and convenience.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of online education?

Online education, which depends on technology and virtual platforms, has its own advantages and challenges. Here’s a simple breakdown of the pros and cons:

Advantages:

• Flexibility: Students learn at their own pace. They revisit lectures and complete assignments according to their own schedule.
• Accessibility: Makes education accessible in remote or mobility constraints areas.
• Cost-effectiveness: Online education is cheaper than traditional classroom teaching as it eliminates travel expenses and the cost of physical materials such as books, uniforms, stationery, etc.
• Different learning styles: Online education may include multimedia aspects such as video lectures, online discussions, and interactive simulations designed for visual, auditory, and kinesthetic learners.

Disadvantages:

• Isolation: Irregular classroom learning can lead to isolation or separation among some students, affecting the development of social connections and teamwork.
• Self-discipline: Managing time effectively and avoiding distractions requires self-control in the absence of a teacher to monitor.
• Not ideal for all subjects: Hands-on learning or subjects that require specific equipment or instruments may not be ideal for online teaching, such as science experiments.
• Technical challenges: Internet connectivity issues or software glitches can interrupt the learning process. This prevents access to the course materials.
• Quality: The quality of online education varies greatly depending on the platform and teacher. This requires careful research on the part of the student.

Why classroom learning is better than online education: A comparison

Do classrooms offer a unique learning experience? Physical presence in the classroom allows for immediate interaction and personalized support from experienced teachers. Classrooms are becoming lively hubs where different ideas come together, providing a well-rounded education that goes beyond online platforms.

As we all know, online education is gaining momentum in India. However, there are seven benefits of classroom learning that online learning technology can never match.

1. Enriches the social development of students

Students learn to interact socially in the classroom and school. Each student has the opportunity to learn to control their emotions and increase their self-confidence, self-esteem and empathy. 

They also strive to develop relationships with their teachers and peers. They develop skills like responsive care, practical help, taking turns, conflict resolution, and cooperation. These skills cannot be acquired through online learning.

For example, daily interaction with peers allows students to form meaningful friendships, share experiences, and develop a sense of cooperation that is often lacking in online learning.

2. Promotes critical thinking

Through various projects and teamwork in class, students acquire new knowledge, ideas and concepts. By learning new concepts and subjects in school, students have the opportunity to develop new skills such as problem solving, assessing, analytical, communication, creativity, and leadership mindset. They gradually develop critical thinking skills as well.

For example, working together on a science project promotes critical thinking and problem-solving as they communicate and discuss diverse ideas and perspectives and work together to come up with solutions.

3. Develop personality and career-building skills

Classroom learning helps develop students’ personality and career skills, such as communication, teamwork and problem-solving. Participating in group projects, discussions and presentations boost their ability to collaborate and express ideas confidently. This helps in shaping well-rounded individuals ready to take on professional challenges with competence.

For instance, participating in a debate about environmental issues will not only improve students’ public speaking skills, but it will also develop their persuasion and critical thinking skills that are essential for career success.

4. Encourages collaborative learning

Once students complete their graduation, they gain important skills required for working in the organization or as an entrepreneur, such as collaboration, cooperation, and adaptability. These skills can be acquired by working on group projects that teach students to communicate, interact, and collaborate, as well as share knowledge, develop ideas, and co-create a final product. 

For example, a group might combine creativity, research, and teamwork to design a poster for an environmental awareness campaign. This requires them to collaborate, divide tasks, and solve problems together.

5. Offers flexible teaching style or method

In classroom learning, teachers can alter the teaching method depending on how well an idea or content is understood by the students. Teachers can fully use the lesson plan to make learning more entertaining and productive. This cannot be done in online teaching. 

For instance, when teaching about volcanoes, teachers can have students build models of volcanoes to learn about eruptions, making science both fun and memorable. They can modify the teaching method if necessary

6. Builds better personality

Students have the opportunity to learn ethical qualities such as diligence, courtesy, generosity, teamwork, and collaboration in the classroom. They are expected to follow academic standards as being disciplined and respectful, maintaining order in the classroom, smiling, and greeting teachers, peers, and other staff members. They can seek assistance when required.

For example, a student excelling in math can tutor a classmate. This encourages mutual respect and collaborative growth. 

7. Enhances student motivation

Class discussions help students express their ideas and opinions during debates. Students observe their teachers and are inspired to perform better. They are motivated when their teachers and peers give them honest feedback and helpful criticism.

For example, if a student presents a science project and the teacher praises them for taking an innovative approach, their classmates will show enthusiasm for the creative idea. This immediate feedback increases students’ interest in the subject and also motivates others to actively participate and put in the extra effort. Learn more about what is better for learning – a teacher or the internet – here.

Classroom teaching vs online education

Some students may prefer the environment and social engagement found in a physical classroom. On the other hand, some students may thrive on the flexibility and self-paced learning offered in online classes. Each has its pros and cons, and the best choice will depend on a student’s learning preferences, personal situation, and academic goals. Let’s take a look at the differences between these two methods:

Feature	Classroom Teaching	Online Education
Structure	Fixed schedule and curriculum	Flexible pace and schedule
Location	Physical classroom	Virtual learning environment
Interaction	Face-to-face with teacher and peers	Primarily virtual interaction
Learning Style	May not cater to all styles	Can cater to diverse learning styles through multimedia
Cost	Typically higher due to overhead costs	Can be lower due to reduced expenses
Distractions	Potential for distractions from classmates	Requires self-discipline to avoid distractions in the learning environment
Social Interaction	Encourages social connection and teamwork	Limited opportunities for social interaction

By considering these aspects, students can choose the method that suits them best and supports them in reaching their academic aspirations.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while online education has its advantages and is an essential part of modern learning, it cannot fully replace the unique benefits of classroom learning and face-to-face teaching. A balanced approach that incorporates both methods can provide students with a more comprehensive and effective educational experience.

FAQs:

1. What is the difference between online teaching and classroom teaching?

The key difference lies in the learning environment. Classroom teaching takes place in a physical space with a set schedule, while online education utilizes virtual platforms for instruction and learning. Here’s a breakdown:

• Structure: Classroom teaching offers a fixed schedule and curriculum. Online education provides flexibility in pace and schedule.
• Location: Classroom based vs. virtual learning environment.
• Interaction: Students interact directly with teachers and peers in a classroom setting. Online education relies primarily on virtual interaction.
• Delivery: Classroom teaching utilizes various methods like lectures, discussions, and activities. Online courses offer multimedia elements like videos, simulations, and discussions.

2. What is the purpose of classroom teaching?

Classroom teaching goes beyond imparting knowledge. It fosters a structured learning environment that promotes:

• Social interaction and collaboration: Students learn from each other through discussions, group projects, and teamwork, developing communication and interpersonal skills.
• Immediate feedback and personalized guidance: Teachers can answer questions, provide feedback, and tailor their approach to individual student needs.
• Development of study habits and time management skills: The set schedule and routine help students establish routines for completing assignments and studying for tests.

3. Will online education one day replace the classroom?

It’s unlikely that online education will entirely replace the classroom. Both approaches have their strengths. However, online education is likely to continue to grow in popularity, offering a valuable alternative for students seeking flexibility and accessibility.

4. What is the importance of classroom teaching?

Classroom teaching provides a unique blend of structure and interaction that can be highly beneficial for students. It fosters:

• Social development: Students build relationships with peers and develop communication and collaboration skills through face-to-face interaction.
• Active learning: The classroom environment encourages participation in discussions, activities, and group projects, promoting engagement and deeper understanding.
• Teacher guidance: Instructors provide immediate feedback, personalized support, and a structured learning environment that can be crucial for success, especially for younger learners.

5. Why are teachers better than the internet?

Teachers offer a personalized and interactive learning experience that the internet cannot match. Unlike static online resources, teachers provide tailored feedback, adapt their methods to meet individual needs, and build meaningful relationships with students. They offer crucial emotional support and mentorship, guide students through structured learning paths, and foster critical thinking and ethical understanding. This human connection and adaptability ensure that education is not only informative but also supportive and engaging, highlighting the irreplaceable role of teachers in the learning process.

6. What is actual classroom teaching?

Actual classroom teaching involves a direct, interactive process where a teacher delivers instruction to students in a physical or virtual classroom setting. This method emphasizes real-time engagement, allowing teachers to present material, facilitate discussions, and address questions immediately. 

7. Why is classroom teaching better than online?

Classroom teaching offers a more interactive and engaging learning environment. In a physical classroom, students benefit from face-to-face interactions with teachers and peers, which can lead to more effective communication and immediate feedback. The structured environment of a classroom helps students stay focused and motivated, reducing distractions that are common in online settings. Additionally, classroom teaching allows for hands-on learning experiences, group work, and real-time discussions that are often more challenging to replicate online. This setting also fosters a sense of community and collaboration, which is vital for social and emotional development.

8. Why is traditional learning better than online learning?

Traditional learning provides a comprehensive educational experience that goes beyond just academic knowledge. It includes social interaction, extracurricular activities, and a routine that supports the holistic development of students. The physical presence of teachers and classmates in traditional learning encourages active participation, critical thinking, and the development of interpersonal skills. Moreover, traditional learning environments offer better access to resources such as libraries, labs, and learning materials, which can enhance the educational experience. While online learning offers flexibility, traditional learning remains a more immersive and structured approach that supports deeper understanding and retention of knowledge.

Related Blogs

7 Essential Online Teaching Tools For Educators and Students

7 Tips for Teaching Emotional Intelligence in Classroom

11 Tips For Teaching Critical Thinking Skills In The Classroom

Importance of teaching digital citizenship and online safety in the classroom

Teachings of Buddha for Children’s Moral Growth and Development